Illegal Smart Tech Floods Online Marketplaces
A recent investigation into smart products on Amazon, eBay, and Temu revealed that nearly 90% of these devices do not comply with new security support transparency laws. These regulations, designed to enhance security standards, require brands to clearly state how long they will support their products with vital updates.
Despite these laws, major brands are still unclear about support durations, and some are outright ignoring the law. The situation is worse on online marketplaces, where numerous smart gadgets fail to meet legal requirements, potentially putting your security at risk.
Non-Compliant Smart Tech on Marketplaces
Many smart products sold online are generic, often originating from Chinese manufacturing hubs like Shenzhen. These devices frequently have security flaws. After the Product Security and Telecommunications Infrastructure Act 2022 (PSTI) took effect on April 29, 2024, we searched for "wireless cameras" and "smart doorbells" on Amazon, eBay, and Temu, excluding second-hand items.
In our research, 248 out of 282 listings (88%) did not comply with the PSTI's update policy, which mandates that brands publish how long they will support a product. Most non-compliance was due to products lacking a brand name or a clear update policy on the listing.
Marketplace Compliance Rates
- Amazon: Had the highest compliance, but still, 68 out of 100 listings (68%) did not meet the requirements. Compliant listings were mostly Amazon brands like Ring or Blink. Interestingly, Amazon has begun publishing software updates information on some listings, despite it not being a legal requirement. However, some listings stated 'Guaranteed software updates until’ as ‘unknown.’
- eBay: Had a 98% non-compliance rate, with only two compliant devices being Amazon Ring doorbells. This highlights a significant issue with the platform's adherence to the new regulations.
- Temu: All 82 products checked did not meet the requirements, with only four recognizable brands among them. This is particularly concerning given Temu's rapid growth as an online marketplace.
These budget-friendly products mimic brands like Ring or Nest but cost significantly less, making them attractive to cost-conscious shoppers. For example, a wireless camera on Temu averaged £15.50, while a smart doorbell on eBay averaged £25.
The Online Marketplace Loophole
Under PSTI legislation, online marketplaces are not classified as retailers, importers, or distributors, so they have limited responsibilities for compliance. This loophole leaves it unclear who is responsible for ensuring these products meet legal standards.
Marketplace Responses
- eBay: Initially stated they would enforce new regulations but later clarified that compliance is the manufacturer's responsibility. They mentioned that sellers would need to adhere to regulations, but did not demonstrate active measures being taken to ensure compliance.
- Amazon: Claimed they would take action against non-compliant products and require sellers to provide additional information. They expressed commitment to removing non-compliant products and engaging with sellers to ensure adherence to the new regulations.
- Temu: Conducted a review and removed non-compliant products, pledging to work with sellers to ensure future compliance. They committed to allowing only those sellers who provide proof of compliance to list their products and stated that they are actively guiding their sellers through the compliance process.
Shopping Smart Tech Safely
Given the prevalence of unbranded smart products online, shoppers need to be cautious:
- Brand Awareness: Be wary of unknown or no-name brands. While established brands can sometimes be more expensive, they often provide clearer information about support and updates.
- Avoid Copycats: Look out for generic tech that mimics popular products. These devices might be cheaper but often lack the security and update guarantees of their more established counterparts.
- Check Reviews: Pay attention to negative reviews for genuine customer feedback. Fake reviews are common, but negative reviews can provide insight into potential security issues or other problems.
Dealing with Unsupported Smart Tech
If you own unsupported smart devices, don't panic. While they pose increased risks, there are ways to mitigate these:
- Check Support Durations: Determine how long your devices will be supported. This information can often be found on the manufacturer's website or by contacting them directly.
- Upgrade Options: Consider upgrading smart TVs with new smart TV sticks. Disconnected smart appliances from Wi-Fi can still be used in their traditional mode.
- Plan for Upgrades: For some devices, upgrading might be the only option. Keep an eye on new products that offer better support and security features.
As smart homes become more common, they may become targets for fraud and cybercrime. Taking security seriously now can help protect against future risks.
Official Government Websites:
- UK Government’s Cyber Aware: Offers advice on how to stay secure online.
- National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC): Provides guidance on securing smart devices and general cyber security tips.
Consumer Protection Organizations:
- Which?: Regularly publishes reviews and articles on smart tech security and compliance.
- Consumer Reports: Offers independent reviews and advice on various consumer products, including smart tech.
Technology and Cybersecurity Publications:
- TechCrunch: Features articles on the latest in tech and security issues.
- Wired: Provides in-depth articles on cybersecurity and tech trends.
- CNET: Offers news, reviews, and how-to guides on smart tech products.
Industry Associations:
- Internet of Things Security Foundation (IoTSF): Aims to make the Internet of Things secure and provides resources for both consumers and manufacturers.
- Cybersecurity & Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA): Offers resources on securing smart devices and understanding potential vulnerabilities.
Online Forums and Communities:
- Reddit’s r/HomeAutomation: A community where users share their experiences and advice on smart home devices.
- SmartThings Community: A forum for discussing smart home technology and security.
Manufacturer Websites:
- Ring: Provides information on product updates and security features.
- Nest: Offers support and security details for their smart products.
- Amazon Devices: Includes information on their smart devices and updates.
Educational Resources:
Local Consumer Protection Agencies:
- Trading Standards UK: Can provide advice and support on consumer rights and product compliance.
- Federal Trade Commission (FTC) - USA: Offers resources on consumer protection and smart tech security.
By exploring these resources, the public can stay informed about smart tech security, ensure they are purchasing compliant products, and learn how to protect their smart devices from potential threats.
Here are some resources from the USA where the public can find more information about smart tech security, compliance with regulations, and tips for safe shopping:
USA Government Websites
Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
- FTC Consumer Information
- Provides resources on protecting your privacy, understanding product compliance, and spotting scams.
Cybersecurity & Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA)
- CISA Cyber Essentials
- Offers practical steps to improve cybersecurity for individuals and businesses, including securing smart devices.
National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)
- NIST Cybersecurity Framework
- Provides guidelines and best practices for improving cybersecurity, including Internet of Things (IoT) devices.
Consumer Protection Organizations
Consumer Reports
- Consumer Reports - Smart Home
- Offers independent reviews, buying guides, and security tips for smart home devices.
Better Business Bureau (BBB)
- BBB Scam Tracker
- Allows consumers to report and track scams, including those related to smart tech products.
Technology and Cybersecurity Publications
Wired
- Wired - Security
- Features in-depth articles on cybersecurity, including vulnerabilities in smart home devices.
CNET
- CNET - Smart Home
- Provides news, reviews, and how-to guides on smart home products and security.
TechCrunch
- TechCrunch - Security
- Offers news and analysis on the latest cybersecurity issues, including smart tech.
Industry Associations
Internet of Things Security Foundation (IoTSF)
- IoTSF
- Provides resources and guidelines to enhance the security of IoT devices.
Cybersecurity Association of Maryland (CAMI)
- CAMI
- Offers resources and events focused on cybersecurity best practices for individuals and businesses.
Online Forums and Communities
Reddit’s r/HomeAutomation
- Reddit - r/HomeAutomation
- A community where users share experiences and advice on smart home devices and security.
SmartThings Community
- SmartThings Community
- A forum for discussing smart home technology and security tips.
Manufacturer Websites
Amazon Devices
- Amazon Devices
- Includes information on their smart devices and updates related to security.
Google Nest
- Google Nest
- Offers support and security details for their smart home products.
Ring
- Ring
- Provides information on product updates and security features for their smart devices.
Educational Resources
Coursera
- Coursera - Cybersecurity Courses
- Offers courses on cybersecurity and smart home technology from top universities.
edX
- edX - Cybersecurity Courses
- Provides online courses on various topics related to cybersecurity and IoT.
Local Consumer Protection Agencies
- State Consumer Protection Offices
- USA.gov - Consumer Protection Offices
- Directory of consumer protection offices by state, offering support and resources for consumer rights and product compliance.
By exploring these resources, consumers in the USA can stay informed about smart tech security, ensure they are purchasing compliant products, and learn how to protect their smart devices from potential threats.
The Dangers of Illegal Smart Tech
1. Security Risks
One of the most pressing concerns with illegal smart tech is the potential for security breaches. These devices often lack the rigorous testing and certification processes that legitimate products undergo, making them more susceptible to hacking, data breaches, and malware attacks. Using an unauthorized smart device could expose your personal information, such as passwords, credit card details, and even your home security system, to cybercriminals.
2. Poor Quality and Reliability
Illegal smart tech products are typically made with substandard materials and components. This can result in poor performance, frequent malfunctions, and a significantly shorter lifespan compared to genuine products. Not only does this waste your money, but it also leads to frustration and inconvenience when the device fails to work as expected.
3. Lack of Support and Warranty
Purchasing illegal smart tech means forfeiting the benefits of customer support and warranty services that come with authorized products. If the device malfunctions or requires updates, you're on your own. This lack of support can be particularly problematic if the device is integral to your home or office setup.
4. Legal Consequences
In some cases, purchasing or using illegal smart tech can lead to legal repercussions. Certain smart devices are subject to regulations and certifications to ensure they meet safety and privacy standards. Using an unauthorized product may violate these regulations, leading to fines or other legal actions.
How to Identify Illegal Smart Tech
1. Unusually Low Prices
If a deal seems too good to be true, it probably is. Illegal smart tech products are often sold at prices significantly lower than their legitimate counterparts. While discounts are common in online marketplaces, extremely low prices should raise red flags.
2. Lack of Brand Information
Legitimate smart tech products are usually sold by reputable brands with clear branding, detailed product descriptions, and official certifications. If the product listing lacks this information or the brand name is unfamiliar, it could be a counterfeit or unauthorized product.
3. No Certification Marks
Authorized smart devices typically carry certification marks, such as CE, FCC, or RoHS, indicating they meet certain safety and environmental standards. The absence of these marks is a strong indicator that the product is illegal or not up to standard.
4. Poorly Written Listings
Illegal products are often listed with poorly written descriptions, vague specifications, and low-quality images. Pay attention to spelling and grammar mistakes, as well as discrepancies between the product description and the images provided.
5. Limited or No Reviews
Legitimate products usually have a significant number of customer reviews. If the product has few or no reviews, or if the reviews seem fake or generic, it could be an illegal smart tech product.
Protecting Yourself from Illegal Smart Tech
1. Buy from Reputable Retailers
One of the best ways to avoid illegal smart tech is to purchase products from reputable retailers or directly from the manufacturer. Authorized sellers are more likely to offer genuine products, along with customer support and warranty services.
2. Research Before You Buy
Before purchasing any smart device, do your research. Look for reviews from verified buyers, check the seller’s reputation, and compare the product with listings on the manufacturer’s official website. This will help you identify any discrepancies and make an informed decision.
3. Verify Certifications
Always check for certification marks on the product and in the listing details. If you’re unsure about a product’s legitimacy, you can verify the certification number on the relevant authority’s website.
4. Report Suspicious Products
If you come across a product that you suspect is illegal or counterfeit, report it to the online marketplace. Most platforms have mechanisms in place to investigate and remove such listings to protect consumers.
5. Use Secure Payment Methods
When purchasing smart tech online, use secure payment methods that offer buyer protection. This can help you recover your money if the product turns out to be illegal or counterfeit.
Red Flags to Look for When Purchasing Smart Tech Online
**1. Unbelievably Low Prices:
- What to Look For: If a smart tech product is being sold at a fraction of the price compared to well-known retailers, it’s a major red flag. Counterfeit or unauthorized products are often priced significantly lower to attract buyers.
**2. Unfamiliar or No Brand Name:
- What to Look For: Legitimate smart tech products are usually associated with well-known brands. If the brand name is unfamiliar, misspelled, or if the product has no branding at all, it could be a sign of an illegal product.
**3. Lack of Certifications:
- What to Look For: Authorized smart tech products typically come with certifications such as CE, FCC, or RoHS, which indicate compliance with safety and environmental standards. The absence of these certifications is a strong indicator that the product may be illegal or unsafe.
**4. Suspiciously High Discounts or Flash Sales:
- What to Look For: Be cautious of websites that constantly offer "limited-time" deals with massive discounts, especially if these deals seem too good to be true. This is often a tactic used to push counterfeit goods.
**5. Poor Website Design and User Experience:
- What to Look For: Legitimate websites usually have professional, user-friendly designs. If a website looks outdated, has broken links, or features low-quality images, it might be a sign that the site is not trustworthy.
**6. No Contact Information or Limited Customer Support:
- What to Look For: Reputable retailers typically provide clear contact information, including a physical address and customer service details. If this information is missing or difficult to find, it’s a red flag.
**7. Lack of Customer Reviews or Fake Reviews:
- What to Look For: Check the reviews on the product and the website itself. If there are very few reviews, if they all seem generic, or if they are overwhelmingly positive in a way that seems unnatural, the product might be illegal or counterfeit.
**8. Strange Payment Methods:
- What to Look For: Be cautious if a website only accepts unusual payment methods, such as wire transfers or cryptocurrencies, instead of credit cards or PayPal. These payment methods are often irreversible and can be used to scam buyers.
**9. Inconsistent or Vague Product Descriptions:
- What to Look For: Legitimate products usually have detailed descriptions, specifications, and clear images. If the product descriptions are vague, overly general, or inconsistent with the images, it could indicate a counterfeit product.
**10. No Return Policy or Ambiguous Terms:
- What to Look For: Reputable sellers offer clear return policies. If a website has no return policy, or if the terms are confusing or restrictive, it’s a red flag that you might be dealing with an illegitimate seller.
Tips for Safe Online Shopping
Stick to Known Retailers: Purchase smart tech from established, well-known retailers or the manufacturer’s official website.
Research the Website: If you’re unfamiliar with a website, look up reviews or complaints about the site before making a purchase.
Use Secure Payment Methods: Always use payment methods that offer buyer protection, such as credit cards or PayPal.
Verify Product Legitimacy: Cross-check the product’s details with the manufacturer’s official website to ensure authenticity.
By being aware of these signs and conducting due diligence, you can significantly reduce the risk of purchasing illegal or counterfeit smart tech products online or call IT-UK Tech Team for help and advice on any smart tech.
Comments